BEST & FAIREST FOOTBALL CLUB MEDALISTS
| Year | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1950 | Bill Luck | Noel Porter | – |
| 1951 | Bill Murphy | Harry Stephens | – |
| 1952 | Ray Preston | Harry Stephens | – |
| 1953 | Frank Howard | Robert McAulliffe | – |
| 1954 | Harry Stephens | Robert McAulliffe | – |
| 1955 | Harry Stephens | Robert McAulliffe | – |
| 1956 | Ken Ormston | Ray Bush Max Osborn |
– |
| 1957 | Kevin Roulent | Ron Wood | Neville Glasson |
| 1958 | John Atkinson | Bill Murphy | Lindsay Powles |
| 1959 | Bernie Vance | Kevin Roulent | Ian Eastway |
| 1960 | Ken Ormston | Kevin Roulent | Angelo Lia |
| 1961 | Bill Roe | Ray Bush | Barry Guy |
| 1962 | Garry Buswell | Kevin Keenan | Barry Ward |
| 1963 | Colin Edwards | Frank Rachele | Dominic Rachele |
| 1964 | Tom Carey | Maurice Mullins | Marco Limosani |
| 1965 | Tom Carey | John Noonan | Lindsay Lohse |
| 1966 | Bernie Sleeth | Alan Power | Frank Davies |
| 1967 | Bernie Vance | Noel Morgan | John Hueston |
| 1968 | Des Campbell | Frank Davies | Gary O'Brien |
| 1969 | Des Campbell | Dominic Lagana | Joe Mammone |
| 1970 | Ross McKellar | Dominic Lagana | Wayne Clayton |
| 1971 | Des Campbell | Jeff O'Brien | Chris Tremellen |
| 1972 | Stephen Westh | Jeff O'Brien | Gary Ralph |
| 1973 | Trevor Eddy | Rob Devlin | John Guilmartin |
| 1974 | Trevor Eddy | Tim Ross-Edwards | Eric Wilson |
| 1975 | Ross Oliver | Greg Handley | Paul Lowe |
| 1976 | Adrian O'Sullivan | Wayne Clayton | Geoff O'Sullivan |
| 1977 | Adrian O'Sullivan | Tony Cole | Geoff Durling |
| 1978 | John Guilmartin | Clayton Doyle | Gary Kitto |
| 1979 | David Ross-Edwards | Clayton Doyle | Brian McCarty |
| 1980 | Eric Wilson | Russell Haack | Gerard McCarty |
| 1981 | Greg McPherson | Ian Petherick | Des Hicks |
| 1982 | Mick Power | Gerard McCarty | Shane Ward |
| 1983 | Des Hicks | Clayton Doyle | Howard Bux |
| 1984 | John Williams | Paul Phillips | Howard Bux |
| 1985 | George Traianids | Tim Conroy | Dean Pattison |
| 1986 | Ross Sidebottom Gary Ralph |
Tony Kennedy | Vincent Zampaglione |
| 1987 | Gary Kitto | Ross Wright | Rohan Hillman |
| 1988 | Phillip Morgan | Tom Zampaglione | Shaun Hart |
| 1989 | Phillip Morgan | Joe DiStefano | Scott Thomlinson |
| 1990 | Gary Kitto | Stuart Joyce | Brenton Cooper |
| 1991 | Peter Foott | Dean Hall | Glenn Greig |
| 1992 | Peter Foott | Jarrod Dempster | Jason Traianidis |
| 1993 | Michael Winter | Danny Russell | Matthew Lane |
| 1994 | Jason Traianidis | Dean Knight | Chris Tamburro |
| 1995 | Chris Kennedy | Grant Scrivens Darren Montgomery |
John Sutherland |
| 1996 | Brad Dobson | Jarrod Dempster | Murray Vance |
| 1997 | Chris Kennedy | Glenn Greig | Luke Shay |
| 1998 | Glenn Greig | Peter Chenery | Matt Vasey |
| 1999 | Justin Crough | Jodie Ashman | Justin Davies |
| 2000 | Russell Gibson | Angelo Greco | Jonse Palmer |
| 2001 | Chris Kennedy | Duane Cannon David Deery |
Tim Richter |
| 2002 | Chris Kennedy | Scott Greig | Jake Cowman |
| 2003 | Chris Kennedy | Scott Greig | Mitchell Moore |
| 2004 | Joel Sofi | Scott Iddles | Joey Perkovic |
| 2005 | Matt Forys | Brent Simmons | Ash Round |
| 2006 | Steve Hazelman | Mathew Kitto | Jarrod Bingham |
| 2007 | Michael Barlow | Pasquale Latorre | Cameron Holdsworth |
| 2008 | Tyson Sidebottom | Pasquale Latorre | James Cullum |
| 2009 | Phillip Carroll | Phillip Haigh | Cameron Hall |
| 2010 | Shaun Huy | Phillip Haigh | Matthew DiBella |
| 2011 | Tyson Sidebottom | Ryan Sidebottom | Matthew Waight |
| 2012 | Matthew Rendina | Brendan Scott | Nick Sneyd |
| 2013 | Brad Henderson | Tommy Scott | Tom Chalkley |
| 2014 | Tim Looby | Damon Carroll | Matthew Cordy |
| 2015 | Shane Neaves | Stephen Scott | Matthew Cordy | 2016 | Tim Looby | Ben Pedretti | Kyle Orchard | 2017 | Reid Crowe | Tom McCluskey | Lachlan Holthusien | 2018 | Shane Neaves | Mitchell McGrath | Blake Fothergill |
| 2019 | Shane Neaves | Ben McCluskey | Will Norman |
| 2020 | |||
| 2021 | Kyle Clarke |